Florida Set to Carry Out 20th Execution of 2026, Breaking All-Time State Record As Thomas Overton Maintains His Innocence

November 18, 2026

TALLAHASSEE, Fla. — Florida is scheduled to execute Thomas Mitchell Overton on Thursday, November 19, at 6 p.m., marking the state’s 20th execution of 2026 and setting an all-time annual record. The execution would surpass the previous record of 19, set just last year, bringing Florida’s total to 39 executions in less than two years.

Overton’s case bears many of the characteristics of capital cases in Florida. He was sentenced to death following two non-unanimous jury recommendations (8–4 and 9–3), but was denied a new penalty phase trial because his conviction became final before an arbitrary cutoff date established by the Florida Supreme Court. He would also be at least the 12th survivor of Florida’s Dozier School for Boys to be executed in the state, and the 15th military veteran executed under Gov. Ron DeSantis. 

Overton was sentenced to death for the 1991 murders of Michael and Susan “Missy” MacIvor in Tavernier Key, FL. He was simultaneously convicted of the death of their unborn child. He has consistently maintained his innocence, and his attorneys have documented extraordinary failures in the investigation, including biological evidence taken home and stored in the personal refrigerator of the Monroe County Sheriff’s Office’s serologist (a veterinarian who took a two-week course in lab techniques), evidence given by police to a psychic and subsequently handled without gloves, and falsified signatures on evidence seals. Fingerprints recovered from critical evidence did not match Overton, while hairs recovered from the tape used to bind the victims have never undergone DNA testing despite repeated requests.

“Thomas Overton’s case sounds outrageous, but the reality is that Florida routinely sends people to death row based on unreliable evidence and deeply flawed investigations. This state has had more people exonerated from death row than any other, yet continues to ignore its own history and proceed with execution after execution without taking seriously the possibility that it could execute an innocent person,” said Grace Hanna, executive director of Floridians for Alternatives to the Death Penalty (FADP).

Overton’s pending Supreme Court petition challenges Florida’s clemency process, arguing that the governor’s categorical refusal to grant clemency to anyone convicted of murder has violated the due process rights of those on death row seeking a final act of mercy. His attorneys write that the “clemency process as it was originally intended no longer exists for death-sentenced inmates in Florida.” The petition also challenges the secrecy surrounding clemency and death warrants, which his attorneys argue prevents access to records needed to contest the process. 

“Clemency is supposed to provide a fail-safe opportunity to consider whether an execution should go forward,” Hanna continued. “If the answer is decided before anyone’s case is considered, that safeguard has been abandoned. As Florida prepares to break its own execution record, the need for meaningful review of each and every case could hardly be more urgent.”

Floridians for Alternatives to the Death Penalty (FADP) is calling on Governor Ron DeSantis to halt Overton’s execution amid a credible claim of innocence and his ongoing U.S. Supreme Court challenge to the constitutionality of Florida’s clemency process. If the execution proceeds, the organization and partners will lead a series of demonstrations and vigils across the state.

###

Download

 

Legal Sources

Circuit Court (Monroe County): 1996CF30167

Florida Supreme Court: SC2026-1724

U.S. Supreme Court: 26A686